What is Gilby's problem w/Storm?

[byteme]

Storm nailed it as usual on 29 Aug and Gilby liked Jill's version better. Gimme a break, I realize this is a game show and Gilby is just playing his part, but the SN dudes need to get more believable as well as the bad editing. E.g. it was clear that Gilby was being booed for his comments on the weird way that the interaction w/Storm ended. Obviously the fans in the room disagreed as did I with Gilby's opinion. It is his band and he can and will choose whomever he wants, but it insults everyone and his fellow professional Storm to give bogus critiques based on nonsense. Storm nailed it, admit the truth and simply state that you do not like her style for your band and move on.

IMO Storm is the best of the lot on all counts, if SN cannot see that then it is their loss.

[pollyblue]

from what i saw on youtube.com: if it's gonna be her, i won't buy the album. she's a gimmick and far from original.

[dragoness]

I don't believe Gilby has any problems with Storm. He's just being HONEST as he is with everyone on the show.And it's always in more the from of ADVICE then judgement. If he likes the particular performance he is usually the first to let them know.

[Pike Pounder]

That's true dragoness. He's never really been one to criticize as an insult- it's always tended to be more like you said- advice.

[stakes]

Only sad that no others had a chance other than Lukas, he was chosen well b4 the end. Too bad they went for looks instead of talent. Mark my words Dilana will go further and higher than SN, I am sad they made the wrong choice.